A free bus pass is one of the plus points about getting older, and a popular reason for visiting council webpages about public transport. Mobility issues in this group can make online applications attractive, particularly as the alternative is often to travel to a library or customer service centre. However, older people tend not to be online every day (42% of those 65+ compared with 73% in the rest of the population), and will be deterred from using the online channel for more complicated things involving, for example proof of eligibility, unless processes are made as simple as they can be and are clearly and simply explained.
County councils in England only.
30% of sites are ranked as very good for this task (4 star) and 18% as good (3 star). When we last tested this task two years ago, eight counties (30%) offered a complete online application. Today, more than half do. However, just having an online application facility does not necessarily mean you have a top site, since one of this group scores sufficiently badly on other key criteria to achieve just two stars, which equates to failing this task under the old Better connected scoring regime. Sites that do not perform well on this task tend to fail on details of presentation and navigation that are set out below. Close reading of individual site reports will enable councils to identify their shortcomings and improve performance by following best practice highlighted here.
Check ‘coverage’ to see if your council has been surveyed. Go to councils page and select your council. Look for link to task report under 2016-17 results
Provide a good or very good online service based on this survey
Better connected rankings
*Discrepancies in the figures are due to rounding off
NB Question highlighted in red is an ‘essential question’ that must be answered correctly for the council to meet the standard for this task. Questions highlighted in blue affect star ranking
|Questions to be answered "Yes"|
|• Would you recommend that other councils look at this implementation as an example of good practice?||22%|
|• Does a Google search lead me to the task?||100%|
|• Can I find out if I qualify for a concessionary bus pass||78%|
|• Can I find out how to apply?||100%|
|• Can I find out what evidence I need to complete my application?||70%|
|• Can I apply online?||52%|
|• Can I find out how to get a replacement for a lost bus pass?||89%|
|• Can I find out what the bus pass entitles me to do?||96%|
|• Does a search for the task description return the correct result listed in the first five results?||93%|
|• Does the home page link me directly to the task?||100%|
|• Does the service landing page provide a prominent link that takes me directly to this task?||96%|
|• Does the A to Z list include this task?||67%|
|Other questions affecting standard achieved|
|• Was the content you reviewed free of any out of date information?||96%|
|• Overall, how do you rate the journey plus task completion?||2.2|
|• Was the content you reviewed concise and free of jargon?||85%|
Most sites were able to answer the questions posed and it was usually easy to find the right section, but the ease of the journey through the information varied.
To apply for an older person’s bus pass, evidence of eligibility and a photograph is required, so this is a slightly more complex online application to implement. Some sites required people to scan and upload proof of address and identity but a few made the process easier for residents by using a credit reference agency to verify these details instead.
The term ‘concessionary travel’ was often used to describe the services on offer here. It’s important to remember that ‘bus pass’ is the common parlance for what we were looking for. When signposting councils need to ensure that familiar terms such as ‘bus pass’ are used in subheadings and added to the A-Z.
The naming of the free bus pass varied and included terms such as ‘Senior Citizen’s bus pass’, ‘Older person’s bus pass’ and ‘Age-related pass’; some sites had localised branded offerings such as ‘Gold Card’ and ‘NoW Card’. Occasionally such brand names would find their way into a top level menu without a supporting explanation, with the result that unfamiliar users are very unlikely to click them. In one case, the council had decided to use the term ‘National bus pass’ right through the content. This could be confusing as some people might conclude this was a pass for national coach journeys or long trips, when the opposite is true since the pass is for travel on local buses only.
Sites that were truly customer focused structured the content according to the audience or type of pass rather than the topic. Rather than describing all forms of ‘concessionary travel’ together, they split the information into the types, so that all the information related to an older person’s bus pass could be found together. This meant that a senior citizen could read relevant information about eligibility without having to skip over content about eligibility for a disabled pass. It makes for a much quicker and smoother journey through the information.
Good content tells people only what they need to know and minimises background detail, particularly in top level introductory content. Thankfully only one site began by explaining the background to the English National Concessionary Travel Scheme. Another very cluttered site inserted detail about council decisions relating to the scheme from a few years ago. This extraneous detail gets in the way of the key information about who can get a pass, when and where they can use it, and how to go about getting one.
On the other hand, in the interests of simplicity and stripping content to the bare minimum, it is possible to go too far and miss out a crucial detail. A couple of sites made this mistake when encouraging people to use the GOV.UK state pension age checker to find out if they were eligible for a pass. The sites failed to mention that men are eligible once they reach the pensionable age of a woman born on the same day, so they must select ‘female’ when asked for gender. Many more sites made a correct statement about this in the eligibility notes, but failed to remind people at the point at which they linked to the checker. The GOV.UK site itself has a page about applying for an older person’s bus pass that simply links to the checker without including this important detail.
It's shame there was no entry in the A-Z because otherwise this task was exemplary. All the information I needed was on one page, concise but thoroughly explained. An excellent experience all round. The online forms were clearly marked and looked well thought out. Well done! A concise yet thorough page of information answering all of our questions.
This was an excellent experience. The content was very concise and very easy to understand and in plain English. It resembles the GOV.UK way of doing things and allowed me to fly through the review. I was impressed it explained the difference between applying online and by post in that you have to scan and upload your proofs if applying online. Well done for a really easy, seamless experience that is a brilliant example to others. Excellent clear landing page, leads to very concise, jargon free content that is very easy to grasp and understand on first reading.
The signposting could be improved, but the content was excellent and very clear. Well done! I particularly liked the information explaining that documentary evidence is NOT needed for online applications. The structure of the information was clear and helpful all the way through. The how to apply section is very good.
The site provides simple information and a good introduction to the online form. Our questions are answered, though at the start of the online form the eligibility date is simplistic - but the full information is found on the main page. Good format of content. The landing page has a prominent link in main part of the page. This is not my favourite example, but nevertheless a very concise and useful set of information. The introduction to the online form is very helpful.
Overall I thought the site handled this topic in an exemplary manner. The content was concise yet very informative and answered all of our questions. There’s an excellent page about applying with clear explanation of the differences in proofs required between online, telephone and in person applications. The site also has an FAQ page with a picture of a card to show you what it will look like.
This site excelled in terms of promoting bus passes, because of the top task structure of the site. The information was concise and delivered in an accessible manner using a question and answer format. Good promotion of the task on the landing page.